Native vs. Non-native mushrooms and what’s at stake…
When it comes to growing mushrooms, most of us are captivated by their beauty, their benefits, and the magic of growing food from something as simple as a bag of straw. But beneath the surface of this fast-growing movement lies an important ecological conversation - one about native species, biosecurity, and the potential risks of introducing non-native fungi into our natural environments.
What Does “Native” Even Mean?
Native /ˈneɪtɪv/ NOUN (of a plant or animal) of indigenous origin or growth.
A “native” species is generally defined as one that has evolved and established itself in a particular region without human intervention. These species have adapted to their environment over centuries — or millennia — forming part of a finely balanced ecosystem with plants, animals, other fungi, and microbes.
In the UK, native fungi include species such as Agaricus campestris (Field Mushroom), Lepista nuda (Wood Blewit), Cantharellus cibarius (Chanterelle), and various Russula and Boletus species. These mushrooms play vital roles — breaking down organic matter, supporting trees through mycorrhizal partnerships, and providing food for wildlife.
In contrast, species like Pink Oyster (Pleurotus djamor) and Yellow Oyster (Pleurotus citrinopileatus) are native to subtropical and tropical regions of Asia. They are prized for their beauty, flavour, and rapid growth — and they’ve become popular with home growers. But they are not naturally part of the UK’s native fungal landscape.
The invasion concern: Could non-native mushrooms become a threat?
There is growing concern in ecological circles that fast-growing, non-native fungi could naturalise in temperate regions — spreading spores into the wild and outcompeting native fungi. Unlike invasive plants or animals, fungi are often harder to track and control because:
They reproduce through airborne spores that can travel kilometres.
They often live invisibly as mycelium within wood, soil, or even plant material.
Many fungi can adapt rapidly, especially opportunistic decomposers like Pleurotus species.
Although there is currently limited documented evidence of pink or yellow oyster mushrooms becoming invasive in the UK, the potential exists - especially as climate conditions shift and imported species become more viable in British habitats.
The challenge of control in a globalised world.
With global trade, tourism and horticulture moving plants, soil and packaging around the world at an unprecedented scale, fungal cross-colonisation is almost impossible to prevent entirely. We know that even local woodlands have been influenced by spores, microbes and seeds that arrived in imported soil or on foreign timber decades ago.
Garden centres, nurseries, timber yards and even home compost heaps may already host fungi from distant lands. And once fungal mycelium becomes established - particularly in woody material - it’s often hard to detect or remove.
But while eliminating all risk is impossible, minimising unnecessary risk is still essential.
What can growers do? Practical steps toward responsible cultivation
At Caley Brothers, we strongly believe that education is key. Growing mushrooms can be a powerful way to connect people with nature, food systems and ecology - and it also comes with a duty of care. Here’s how we, and our community, can grow sustainably and responsibly:
1. Grow indoors.
Always grow tropical species like pink or yellow oysters indoors. Avoid growing non-native fungi directly on logs or in open beds, where spores can spread uncontrolled.
2. Avoid composting spent substrate outdoors.
Spent mushroom substrate (SMS) may still contain live mycelium. Instead of composting it outdoors where it could colonise new environments, dispose of it responsibly - our advise is to let your substrate dry our naturally and then dispose of along with your own house waste - avoiding putting it into your food waste, garden or compost.
3. Source spawn ethically.
Buy mushroom spawn from reputable UK-based suppliers. Many have robust quality control and ensure strains are suitable for cultivation without increasing ecological risks.
4. Don’t dump kits into nature.
We often hear of well-meaning gardeners burying spent kits “to see what happens.” While tempting, this could allow non-native mycelium to take hold in natural soil systems. Better to contain your curiosity - and your compost.
5. Choose native species for outdoor cultivation.
There are excellent native (or widely naturalised) choices for logs and beds - including Pleurotus ostreatus (Grey Oyster) and Flammulina velutipes (Velvet Shank). Lentinula edodes (Shiitake) and Hericium erinaceus, (Lion’s Mane) though not native, are considered low risk when contained to logs and not grown near sensitive woodland areas).
Conclusion: Celebrate mushrooms, but grow with care.
Mushrooms are among nature’s most powerful recyclers, healers and storytellers. But with great growth comes great responsibility. As more people discover the joys of home growing, we believe the best way forward is education, transparency and empowerment - giving people the tools to grow well and grow wisely.
By understanding where our mushrooms come from and how they interact with the ecosystems around them, we can make conscious choices that benefit both people and planet. At Caley Brothers, we’re not just growing mushrooms - we’re growing awareness, one shroom at a time.
If you have any questions or curiosities during your growing journey, be sure to explore our FAQs and troubleshooting blog. Each post offers insights into the fascinating world of mushroom growing - from the simplicity of our easy-grow kits to helpful advice when nature takes an unexpected turn.
We believe that understanding the basics not only helps you grow more successfully but also deepens your appreciation for the natural world. Growing mushrooms is as much about working with nature as it is about harvesting delicious results.
Happy growing
Ⓒ Caley Brothers 2025
Latest from the blog
